basically, in my CoS game I had a player say they wanted to use a Bonus Action to apply Holy Water to make their attack magical for 1 attack (they are level 1-2 during this time). I say wow, that’s a unique interaction sure! Keep in mind, no damage addition only making the attack magical. I inform the party later that we are limiting a Holy Water flask to 2 charges and a vial to 1 charge.
Later, my friend is messaging me about how he thinks its completely broken and ruins the resource management of the game. I inform him that the party only has like 4 more vials of holy water and the party is about to have access to the Magic Weapon spell in like 2 sessions. Making 1 attack do 12 instead of 6 damage isnt breaking anything in my opinion when it uses the Bonus Action and a limited use item they have no way or mass producing (im limiting Ceremony spam as I said there’d be consequences for sitting around for days mass making it).
Is he over reacting or am I missing something?
submitted by /u/Odande
[link] [comments]
r/DnD basically, in my CoS game I had a player say they wanted to use a Bonus Action to apply Holy Water to make their attack magical for 1 attack (they are level 1-2 during this time). I say wow, that’s a unique interaction sure! Keep in mind, no damage addition only making the attack magical. I inform the party later that we are limiting a Holy Water flask to 2 charges and a vial to 1 charge. Later, my friend is messaging me about how he thinks its completely broken and ruins the resource management of the game. I inform him that the party only has like 4 more vials of holy water and the party is about to have access to the Magic Weapon spell in like 2 sessions. Making 1 attack do 12 instead of 6 damage isnt breaking anything in my opinion when it uses the Bonus Action and a limited use item they have no way or mass producing (im limiting Ceremony spam as I said there’d be consequences for sitting around for days mass making it). Is he over reacting or am I missing something? submitted by /u/Odande [link] [comments]
basically, in my CoS game I had a player say they wanted to use a Bonus Action to apply Holy Water to make their attack magical for 1 attack (they are level 1-2 during this time). I say wow, that’s a unique interaction sure! Keep in mind, no damage addition only making the attack magical. I inform the party later that we are limiting a Holy Water flask to 2 charges and a vial to 1 charge.
Later, my friend is messaging me about how he thinks its completely broken and ruins the resource management of the game. I inform him that the party only has like 4 more vials of holy water and the party is about to have access to the Magic Weapon spell in like 2 sessions. Making 1 attack do 12 instead of 6 damage isnt breaking anything in my opinion when it uses the Bonus Action and a limited use item they have no way or mass producing (im limiting Ceremony spam as I said there’d be consequences for sitting around for days mass making it).
Is he over reacting or am I missing something?
submitted by /u/Odande
[link] [comments]