What did you think would happen in the story during your first play through? /u/Less_Awareness8069 Red Dead Redemption

I’ll go first:

I thought Micah would turn out to be like the Trevor Phillips of the Red Dead franchise, which I guess he kinda is, but I thought he would be a sadistic, yet loyal member of the gang. I think his dialouge about caring too much about the gang during “Blessed are the Peacemakers” was the thing that had me thinking this, as he seemed to let his guard down and actually open up to Arthur and Dutch about his faults… of course, it turned out he was just conning them.

I also thought that Trelawny would be the Rat, because he always knew where the gang was camping out, was always mysteriously vanishing from the camp and was NEVER present whenever they were confronted by the Pinkertons on numerous occasions.

In the epilouge, as soon as Charles started talking about moving North to start a family, I was 90% confident he was gonna die during the mission, and then when he got sniped I was 100% sure. But as I progressed in the mission and Sadie got stabbed I was thinking “Oh God, Charles was a red herring, Sadie is gonna die” but it turns out neither of them did.

I’ll go first:

I thought Micah would turn out to be like the Trevor Phillips of the Red Dead franchise, which I guess he kinda is, but I thought he would be a sadistic, yet loyal member of the gang. I think his dialouge about caring too much about the gang during “Blessed are the Peacemakers” was the thing that had me thinking this, as he seemed to let his guard down and actually open up to Arthur and Dutch about his faults… of course, it turned out he was just conning them.

I also thought that Trelawny would be the Rat, because he always knew where the gang was camping out, was always mysteriously vanishing from the camp and was NEVER present whenever they were confronted by the Pinkertons on numerous occasions.

In the epilouge, as soon as Charles started talking about moving North to start a family, I was 90% confident he was gonna die during the mission, and then when he got sniped I was 100% sure. But as I progressed in the mission and Sadie got stabbed I was thinking “Oh God, Charles was a red herring, Sadie is gonna die” but it turns out neither of them did.