Question about Clean Architecture /u/Icy-Manufacturer7319 CSCQ protests reddit

In Clean Architecture, why we do something like this:

my-project/

│

├── models/

│ └── user.java

│ └── product.java

│

├── repositories/ #fetch database

│ └── userRepository.java

│ └── productRepository.java

│

├── service/ #business logic

│ └── userService.java

│ └── productService.java

rather than this:

my-project/

│

├── user/

│ └── userModel.java

│ └── userRepository.java
│ └── userService.java

│

├── product/

│ └── productModel.java

│ └── productRepository.java
│ └── productService.java

I think the second one easier to maintain cus every code in a file there related to each other, the folder are whole entity but not violate clean architecture cus still isolated. I just think using first approach just too much work if your project got bigger, navigate between folder that contain lots of entity, make me confused and cant focus to just 1 entity😭

In Clean Architecture, why we do something like this:

my-project/

│

├── models/

│ └── user.java

│ └── product.java

│

├── repositories/ #fetch database

│ └── userRepository.java

│ └── productRepository.java

│

├── service/ #business logic

│ └── userService.java

│ └── productService.java

rather than this:

my-project/

│

├── user/

│ └── userModel.java

│ └── userRepository.java
│ └── userService.java

│

├── product/

│ └── productModel.java

│ └── productRepository.java
│ └── productService.java

I think the second one easier to maintain cus every code in a file there related to each other, the folder are whole entity but not violate clean architecture cus still isolated. I just think using first approach just too much work if your project got bigger, navigate between folder that contain lots of entity, make me confused and cant focus to just 1 entity😭